STRANGE TALES #121: Clips and Quips and Sinking Ships

Published: June, 1964

Published: June, 1964

“Prisoner of the Plantman!”
Script: Stan Lee
Art: Dick Ayers
Letters: Art Simek

In honor of our newly revamped Plantman, I’ve decided to approach this story in a “Clips and Quips” format. Imagine this story is a rose bush, and I’m clipping a few of the most beautiful flowers for a bouquet of outstanding moments. Some of these roses honor the artist, others the writer. Some are silly, others sublime, but it’s all working together in an exquisite arrangement of fun and fancy.

FOLIAGE MAKES THE MAN
In Strange Tales #113, Plantman was attacked by “vengeful plants,” and yet now he’s creating another ray-gun. My first thought is, “Will he never learn?” But this time, the plants do not turn on their master. No explanation is given, but I have a theory: Maybe the plants have developed a deeper respect for Plantman, due to his new costume?

LETTUCE ENTERTAIN YOU
st121carIn his second incarnation as Plantman, Sam Smithers devises a more dramatic, more organic, costume. Well, really, he has to, if he wants anyone to take him seriously. The green coat and hat simply weren’t screaming “Super-Villain!” Now he truly looks the part. However, the image of a giant head of lettuce cruising along in a blue convertible is also sort of hard to take seriously.

SO, WE MEET AGAIN!
st121plantmanWhen Plantman appears in Johnny’s room, in the grand Marvel tradition, Johnny announces him, with “PLANTMAN!!!” (three exclamation points) and then adds the ever-popular, “I should have guessed!!” I’m not sure why Johnny thinks he should have guessed. Last time they met, Plantman was shabbily dressed in a green coat and hat. But I guess when a giant head of lettuce flies through your bedroom window, Plantman is a good assumption.

THE FACE OF EVIL
st121smithersst121acornsDick Ayers gives us a villain who, with a gleam in his eyes and a sneer on his lips, looks truly demented. As Johnny quips when the cops show up: “He looked better with the mask ON!” Agreed.

FROM TINY ACORNS…
We know Torch’s kryptonite is everyday H2O, but see how easily Plantman is able to put him out of commission with MOIST ACORNS. Really? Not cool. I hope Doctor Doom and Paste-Pot Pete don’t discover this secret weapon.

HOW COULD YOU FORGET?
And now for some quips! This story was truly amusing in parts, especially when Torch and Plantman exchange boasts. First, we have a back and forth bit I like to call, “You forget…”

Johnny: Too bad you forgot I can FLY!

Plantman: I didn’t forget! I was PREPARED for that!

And later:

Plantman: You forget—I’m still master of plants—and I have many more powerful allies…such as the CACTUS!

Johnny: YOU forgot something, too! I can STILL generate enough body heat to MELT their quills!

At this point, I’ve totally forgotten that once upon a time, Strange Tales was my least favorite of the Marvel comics. I’m having a blast!

SURPIRSE, SURPRISE!
Next, we get this delightful exchange of one-upsmanship:

Plantman: I’m too clever not to have left myself an OUT!

Johnny: You’re bluffing and you know it!

Plantman: Think so?? (and goes on to explain how he’s keeping Doris Evans captive)

Johnny: Plantman, have I got a surprise for YOU! I expected something like this, so… (and goes on to explain how Thing is guarding Doris)

MORE, PLEASE
This is great stuff! Last time we visited Plantman, I remarked that a villain who controls all the foliage on the planet could be a formidable force. I’ve gained a lot more respect for Plantman in this outing. Even though he’s arrested in the end, the last time we see him, he’s uttering that classic super villain promise, “You haven’t heard the last of me! This is only the beginning for Plantman!”

Oh, let’s hope.

st121banner


st121thumb“Witchcraft in the Wax Museum!”
Script: Stan Lee
Art: Steve Ditko
Letters: Art Simek

In our accompanying Doctor Strange story, there’s entirely too much ectoplasm flying around. It all begins when Strange gets a telephone call. I don’t know why, but the image of Dr. Strange, with his high collar, gloved hands, and severe widow’s peak, talking on a telephone strikes me as…dare I say it?…strange. People who regularly wear magical amulets should not be talking on telephones. I mean…whatever happened to good old-fashioned telepathy?

st121phoneStrange decides to travel via his ectoplasmic self, so he can more quickly answer the telephoned summons for help. But arriving at the source of the call, he finds he’s been duped, lured into danger by a recording device.

So he returns home, only to find his old enemy Mordo has stolen his body! Seems if ectoplasmic and physical bodies remain separated for more than 24 hours, both will perish. Strange searches for his carefully hidden body, but Mordo slows him down with a series of ectoplasmic enemies, until only one hour remains. Talk about a sinking ship!

As the clock ticks down to disaster, Strange suddenly remembers that he can use his amulet to recreate the light waves of past events. I guess those ectoplasmic battles kept him so busy for so long, this vital piece of information escaped him…for 23 hours!!

But anyway…now that he’s got his wits about him, Strange aims the amulet, and follows the shadows of the past to the wax museum. With only ten minutes left to live, he finally finds his body. But Mordo has placed an impenetrable spell over it!

Now that Strange is thinking clearly (I guess he works best under pressure), he tricks Mordo into believing he has given up, and is going off to die quietly in a corner somewhere. But, as Strange leaves the premises…surprise! A wax figure warrior comes to life and captures Mordo. Physically bound and gagged, Mordo’s ectoplasmic self escapes.

Now here’s where it gets tricky.

st121clockThe ectoplasmic rival forms of Strange and Mordo battle, and Mordo seems to win, but we quickly discover that was not REALLY ectoplasmic Strange fighting ectoplasmic Mordo. It was only “a figure image” of Strange’s ectoplasmic self. The REAL ectoplasmic Strange binds the ectoplasmic Mordo in what looks like a wad of foul chewing gum, so that he (ectoplasmic Strange) can return to his physical body.

Then Strange does that Noble Hero Thing. Though Mordo tried to kill him, and he now has his arch-rival in a position where he can put an end to all his dastardly deeds forever, he refuses, citing “for I have vowed never to take a life, no matter how deserving it may be of death!” Still, Strange makes another vow: he will keep ectoplasmic and physical Mordo separated for 23 hours, just to torment him.

That tormenting part is actually not so Noble. But I guess he’s trying to Teach Him a Lesson.

And, at last, as Strange disappears into the night with his cloak dramatically billowing around him, he boldly proclaims that “evil can never triumph over the force of good!”

What a show of bravado! But, I have to wonder: is it false bravado, or has Strange completely forgotten that he was within ten minutes of death? Does that mean nothing to him? Is Strange, like Daredevil, a man without fear? Or is he perhaps, only, a man without BRAINS?

If I were Strange, at this point I wouldn’t be walking away into the dead of night with my cape billowing dramatically around me, declaring that evil can never triumph over good. I would be taking a long, hard look at everything that just happened, just in case there might be a Lesson To Be Learned.

May I suggest: Do unto others before they do unto you?

When Strange had Mordo trapped in the chewing gum and allowed him to live, Mordo quickly predicted, “Your refusal to finish me will prove to be your undoing!” Well…it might. Or it might not. In the real world—yes, it would. But, being that we’re in a comic book world, and Strange is our hero, my money’s on “might not.”

Now, one of two things is going on here. Either, Strange is, in fact, a Noble Fool, correctly labeled by his arch-enemy Mordo, or…he’s keenly aware that he’s living in a comic book world, and so he decides to keep Mordo around, so he can toy with him, in further battles, which st121cloakwill be dramatically documented within the back pages of Strange Tales, allowing him further opportunities to walk off into the dead of night, spouting grandiose platitudes from behind his high collar and billowing cape.

Works for me.

ff27tease2But wait! Doctor Strange can’t head home and hang up his cape quite yet! One more adventure awaits him this month. So join me next time, when the good doctor’s mysticism mingles with the majesty of the sea and the finery of the four, in yet another star-studded adventure…right here in the Marvelous Zone!

Want to read this comic on your computer? Marvel has a scan!
Want to own the Human Torch story? Buy the Masterworks!
Want to own the Doctor Strange story? Buy the Masterworks!
Posted in Doctor Strange, Human Torch, Strange Tales | 7 Comments

Meanwhile…: May, 1964

AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #12

asm12“Unmasked By Dr. Octopus!”
Script: Stan Lee
Art: Steve Ditko
Letters: Art Simek

IN A NUTSHELL
A sick Peter dons his Spider-Man costume to rescue Betty from Dr. Octopus. When Doc Ock unmasks his fallen foe, everyone assumes Peter is impersonating Spidey in order to save Betty. The next day, when Peter is better and feeling like a zillion bucks, Spidey helps the police catch the zoo animals Doc Ock has set free. Then Spidey and Ock fight, ending up in a sculptor’s studio, which catches fire. Spidey escapes, but Ock is arrested. Though Liz is now impressed with Peter, he turns down her party invitation, preferring Betty’s company.

WHAT’S HOT
PRIORITIES, PART I. Dr. Octopus engages in a series of “colorful crimes,” stealing bags of money wherever he can, yet his true objective is not monetary gain. His crime spree is merely a ploy to draw Spider-Man out into the open, so he can DESTROY him. Like the other Marvel doctor (Doom…not Strange), Ock is quickly becoming a villainously focused force, slated to cause even greater troubles for the object of his obsession.

PRIORITIES, PART II. Our lesser bad guy, Jameson, gets a stern tongue-lashing from a policeman for withholding information from the law, in order to get an exclusive news story. It was good to finally see somebody put him in his place.

UNREQUITED. Liz Allan is so impressed by the story that Peter impersonated Spider-Man, she now prefers him to Flash. However, since Peter is now all about Betty, he’s no longer interested in Liz, and unapologetically tells her so.

SCENERY. Most of the story ends up being a battle between hero and villain, but extra points for shifting the action across a variety of venues, including a sculptor’s studio that catches fire.

HEROICS. When Doc Ock is trapped beneath a fallen sculpture, Spider-Man’s immediate reaction is “Hang on, smart guy! I’ll get you out!” Spoken like a true hero.

RATIONALIZATION. When Doc Ock is captured, he reasons “Spider-Man didn’t beat me! It was the fire!” Ego still intact, he lives to fight another day.

WHAT’S NOT
CHEAT? Marvel circumvents the DC cheat tradition of “hoax, dream, imaginary story” by having the event promised on the cover actually happen…but no one believes it! So, they’re not being dishonest. But in a way, it still feels like a cheat.

VIRUS. A common virus can make Spider-Man “weak as a kitten.” Superman has less of a chance of running into kryptonite. Peter better be careful and wash his hands–whenever he’s not using them to shoot webs!

PERSPECTIVE? In the last panel, we learn that while Spider-Man and Doctor Octopus were fighting, the automatic shutter of Peter’s camera was clicking away, providing Jameson with the desired pix. Anybody with half a brain would have to wonder about the perspective on those pix. Where was the photographer standing? Or hanging? And how desperate must Jameson be for a “scoop” that he lets himself stupidly gloss over those questions?

asm12banner


FANTASTIC FOUR #26

ff26“The Avengers Take Over!”
Script: Stan Lee
Pencils: Jack Kirby
Inks: George Bell
Letters: Art Simek

IN A NUTSHELL
Thing battles Hulk on the streets of NY, to no avail. Hulk hijacks a subway to Tony Stark’s mansion and finds…the Avengers! Fighting ensues. The FF join the fight against Hulk, but all these superheroes keep getting in each other’s way, and Hulk escapes with a kidnapped Rick Jones. More fighting ensues, but now the superheroes are working together. When Rick slips Hulk a gamma-ray capsule, he reverts to Bruce Banner as he falls into the harbor. The FF and Avengers congratulate each other.

WHAT’S HOT
ALPHA OVERLOAD. The more the merrier, and with all these superheroes getting in each other’s way, there’s plenty of opportunity to see how they interact with each other–with both heroic and comic results.

HIGH PRAISE. My favorite line: When Thing meets Thor, he’s impressed, and marvels, “You’ve even got muscles in your voice.” Could there possibly be any higher praise?

BROMANTIC JEALOUSY. Hulk is mad at Captain America because he’s “the one who tried to get Rick away” from him. In all this muscle vs. muscle, it’s refreshing to see this little bit of soap opera motivation.

WHAT’S NOT
OH, REALLY? When the army guys are convinced Thing and Torch can’t stop Hulk, that’s when they decide to step in. If Thing and Torch can’t get the job done, what makes them think they’ve got a snowball’s chance in Hell of succeeding? They’re either extremely dedicated…or simply delusional.

DO THE MATH. Hulk says that he is only half Giant-Man’s size. Well…IF Giant-Man is twelve feet tall, that would make Hulk only six feet tall…which can’t possibly be true. I think Hulk’s been hit one too many times in the head by this point, and doesn’t know what he’s saying.

ff26banner


JOURNEY INTO MYSTERY #104

jim104“Giants Walk the Earth!”
Script: Stan Lee
Pencils: Jack Kirby
Inks: Chic Stone
Letters: Sam Rosen

IN A NUTSHELL
To confront Thor about his love for a mortal, Odin visits earth, leaving Loki in charge. Loki releases Skagg and Surtur, and sends them to earth to defeat Odin. But Heimdall alerts Balder, who alerts Thor, who alerts Odin, who stops time so the Asgardians can battle on earth. Naturally the good guys beat the bad guys, and when Odin returns home, he sends Loki to “serve the trolls.” Thor, meanwhile, defies his father’s order to return to Asgard, saying he can never leave the home of the one he loves.

WHAT’S HOT
ACTION PACKED. This story has a nice blend of soap opera and action. We begin with some up close and personal scenes, between Blake and Jane, and between Loki and Odin, but the pace quickly picks up with an epic battle including giants, fireballs, storms and funnel clouds, magic swords and asteroids. Reading this story, I could easily see it being the preliminary script for the next Thor movie.

CONTINUITY. It all begins with Loki chastising the Enchantress and the Executioner for their failure in Journey Into Mystery # 103. At the same time, Jane is exhausted after her recent run-in with these two Asgardians. So recent, in fact, she hasn’t yet had time to fully recover from it all! Is this happening the same day?? Nice way to keep the universe alive between issues!

WHAT’S NOT
CONTINUITY. Now, after I’ve just praised the excellent sense of continuity between the last two issues, I regret to say I have a beef with some of the continuity within this issue. Because Jane is exhausted, Blake sends her home for the afternoon, “then, after Jane has left…” he has a weird sense of impending doom, and morphs to Thor so he can “search the entire city in less time than it would take Don Blake to cross a street.” A lot happens in Asgard while Thor is searching the city (“in less time than it would take Don Blake to cross a street”). Well, maybe time passes differently in Asgard? But the next time we see Thor, Balder has arrived on earth to warn him that Odin, Surtur and Skagg are in town and “there is no time to lose!”

Thor prays the warning has come in time. There’s a real sense of urgency to it all, so Thor immediately returns to Blake’s office…and what does he find? Jane is there, attending a waiting room full of patients! (We have a partial view of the room, and see at least three people, besides Odin.) Again, I ask: is this all happening the same day? It certainly seems like it! So, either I’m missing something, or Jane’s just had the shortest afternoon off…ever!

And then, only a few moments after leaving that crowded waiting room, Odin causes time to stand still. Yet, when all the important action is over and he releases the spell, Blake returns to the office and it’s empty, except for Jane, who’s sitting at the desk, reporting, “Actually, it’s been a very quiet day so far!” I understand this is said to increase the sense of irony between the epic battle we’ve just witnessed and the simply mundane lives of us earthlings in comparison, but…but…what happened to all those people in the waiting room? Did they all just decide to stop waiting? “Oh, that Dr. Blake! He’s never around when you need him! I’m going down the street to Dr. Andrews!” (LINK TO JIM 97)

PUNY, STUPID GOD. Okay, one more beef, and unfortunately, this seems to be a recurring one. I don’t understand what’s so hot about Odin. He’s distraught about his “favored son” Thor, so completely at a loss, he asks advice from Loki. Is this really wise? Isn’t Odin aware of what a troublemaker Loki has always been? Is Odin completely oblivious to Loki’s sibling rivalry with Thor? What in the world (our world, or the Asgardian world) makes him think LOKI is going to offer advice that will cause a favorable result for THOR?

And hey, isn’t Loki supposed to be locked up, anyway? What’s he doing running around Asgard, stirring up more mischief? Did I forget something?

Most disturbing of all: even if Odin is at his wit’s end, he’s the King and he’s a GOD. He shouldn’t be admitting to anyone that he has no idea what to do. It demeans his kingship and his godship.

I’m sort of losing respect for Odin.

And when he decides to go to earth, why does he invest Loki with a portion of his power? Doesn’t he have a vice-God, some second in command who would naturally assume that position? Why does he give his power to an ex-con, whose moniker includes the subtitle “God of MISCHIEF”??

Things must really work differently in Asgard.
And/or…
Odin is pretty stupid for a “god.”

jim104banner


STRANGE TALES #120

st120“The Torch Meets the Iceman!”
Script: Stan Lee
Pencils: Jack Kirby
Inks: Dick Ayers
Letters: Sam Rosen

IN A NUTSHELL
A band of pirates led by the Barracuda board a pleasure cruise, unaware Torch and Iceman are passengers. The teen superheroes quickly learn to work together, but Barracuda tricks Torch into falling into the ocean. With the ship on fire, Iceman extinguishes the flames, and captures the pirates, with giant snowballs, even as Johnny lassos the bad guys in a ring of fire. When Barracuda kidnaps Doris, Iceman and Torch rescue her. They leave the scene with great respect for each other’s talents.

WHAT’S HOT
IT HAD TO HAPPEN. The cover proclaims “It had to happen…” and isn’t that the truth? When you’ve got so many supernatural beings whose powers are in direct contradiction to each other, how much fun is it to get them together? On the splash, we learn that this is “the action-packed meeting your letters have demanded!” I don’t doubt readers were waiting for this. And I don’t doubt we’ll see these two in action together again.

MARKETING. The newspaper Johnny’s reading in the splash has the headline “X-Men Battle Brotherhood of Evil Mutants!” from last month’s X-Men comic adventure. The Marvel Bullpen has never been above a hefty dose of self-promotion.

WHAT’S NOT
STUPID CRIMINALS STRIKE AGAIN. What kind of pirates attack a ship full of teenagers in the 1960’s? Nowadays, they might get a good haul of cell phones and credit cards, but in 1964, what could they expect? A few Vitalis-laden hair combs, a Giant-Man Fan Club membership card or two, and some Bazooka bubble gum? Hardly seems worth the effort.

st120banner1

st120b“The House of Shadows!”
Script: Stan Lee
Art: Steve Ditko
Letters: Sam Rosen

When a TV reporter enters a haunted house, Dr. Strange observes through his amulet. When the reporter faces danger, Strange enters the house and confronts the enemy within: the house itself, which has come “from another space-time continuum” to observe mankind. Strange banishes the house to the shadow world, and the crowd thinks it’s trick photography.

It’s a well-documented fact that I am not a fan of the horror genre. That being said, I have no problem watching Buffy, Angel, Teen Wolf, etc. Vampires and werewolves don’t bother me, because in my mind, they so clearly exist only in the world of my imagination. However, don’t talk to me about ghosts, and don’t talk to me about haunted houses. That’s where I draw the line, because (in my mind) these things could be real.

So far, I’ve seen Dr. Strange battle Nightmare, Mordo, body-snatchers, powerful beings from an alternate dimension, and a spinybeast. Yet I have no problem getting to sleep at night.

However, this story creeps me out.

It’s not difficult to imagine the basic premise: the discovery of something spine-chilling within a “haunted house.” How many movies rely on this age-old theme? And nowadays, haunted houses are a hot topic on many cable channels, as well.

I doubt I will ever meet a vampire, werewolf or entity “from another space-time continuum.” But I live in a house. Have lived in houses all my life, and expect to go on living in houses. Houses are real. People are also real, and people die. And if people who die don’t find eternal rest, they could be hanging around as ghosts, and haunting houses.

So, you see…this could happen.

I’m grateful Stan decided to delve into the mystical, fantastical world of his imagination to create a “villain” from “another space-time continuum.” Phew! Now I’m just reading a STORY. But if he had allowed the villain to be an actual ghost, then it would have been less like a “story,” and more like a real possibility.

I’m also grateful this whole thing takes place on cheap newsprint, with word balloons. And that Dr. Strange is so…strange looking. Because if this story had been told as an expertly crafted movie directed by Wes Craven, starring Viggo Mortensen as Dr. Strange, first of all…I probably wouldn’t watch it. But if I did, I might be keeping one eye open when I turn off the bedroom light tonight.

st120banner2


TALES OF SUSPENSE #53

tos53“The Black Widow Strikes Again!”
Plot: Stan Lee
Script: Don Rico
Art: Don Heck
Letters: Sam Rosen

IN A NUTSHELL
After Stark perfects an anti-gravity device, Black Widow wheedles her way into his office, paralyzes him, and escapes with the device. When her bumbling comrades use it to float a car, Iron Man finds them and fighting ensues. Believing she has crushed Iron Man with the device, Black Widow goes after Fort Knox. Iron Man makes a surprise appearance and nullifies the anti-gravity device with a proton electric charge. Oh yeah…and he also saves the lives of the two bumbling comrades, as the Black Widow escapes…yet again.

WHAT’S HOT
MUCH HANDSOMENESS. All of the men in this issue look very rugged and handsome, even the incidental cops at the end of the story. Lots of strong jawlines. I’m really enjoying Don Heck’s artwork in the Iron Man series. Now, having said that, I can’t find much more that goes in the plus column for this story. So without further ado…

WHAT’S NOT
BLIND CHANCE. When Stark works on his anti-gravity device for months without success, he decides to “leave it to blind chance.” WHAT?? One: that’s not the scientific method. Two: it could be highly dangerous. Three: if the methodless madness happens to be successful (as it is), how do you proceed from here?

DUPLICATION OF EFFORTS. Stark should have checked in with the Wizard from the recent Strange Tales story. Of course, the Wizard floated into the stratosphere with his anti-gravity device, so he’s probably not around for consultation. But perhaps he left some notes?

THE PESKY PRESS. How does a snooping reporter get into a top military site to snap a picture of a new weapon in action? I’m losing faith in the U.S. Government, almost as much as I’m losing faith in Tony Stark. Because…

CARELESSNESS. The narrator tells us, “It seems that Tony Stark isn’t the first to be taken in by a pair of limpid eyes,” right before Black Widow charms him and steals the anti-gravity device. Is the narrator excusing Stark’s stupidity as a natural consequence of having overactive male hormones?

‘I MEANT TO DO THAT…” Yet, later, after the Black Widow has stolen the anti-gravity device, Tony reasons, “I KNEW she was up to no good, but I had to pretend I trusted her…to learn what she was after!” Well…which was it? Foolishly taken in by a pair of limpid eyes, calculated planning…or deluded compensation? At least one senator isn’t buying, and labels Stark’s carelessness as “almost criminal negligence.”

WOMEN! YOU CAN’T LIVE WITH ‘EM… In the flashback, as Stark allows Black Widow to escape, he reasons, “After all, she IS just a woman…and such a lovely one!” Two fabulous reasons to let a dangerous criminal go free. Personally, I think Stark is just making some more excuses for his overactive male hormones.

tos53banner1

tos53b“The Way It Began…”
Plot: Stan Lee
Script & Pencils: Larry Lieber
Inks: Paul Reinman
Letters: Art Simek

The Watcher tells the story of how his utopian society, long ago, shared the secrets of nuclear energy with their neighboring planet, Prosilicus. The Prosilicans used that power to create unbeatable weapons to destroy their enemies, and eventually, they destroyed themselves. Devastated by these unintended consequences, the powers-that-be on the Watcher’s planet vowed that from that day forward they would no longer interfere with other planets. They would only…watch

What we have here is a strong anti-war message cloaked in a mythical tale. At the end of the story, the Watcher’s father laments, “I entrusted an enormous power to people who had neither the advanced intellect nor the moral fiber to use it wisely!” Well, isn’t that always the case? No one on earth has yet advanced to that Star Trek-esque idealized amalgam of intellect and moral fiber which makes such enormous power a safe thing.

And speaking of Star Trek, why does the High World Council travel the galaxy to share their knowledge with distant unknown worlds? That makes about as much sense as Captain Kirk and his science officer being a part of every dangerous “Away Team” mission. There are 428 crew members on board…and Kirk and Spock don’t want to give anyone else a chance to go where no man has gone before?

Another question: Why does High World Council member Emnu say, “I, Emnu, disagree!” Does he forget his own name? Or, for all his advanced ways, has he not yet perfected the comic book tradition of referring to oneself in the third person? Of course, he’s got “Bah!” down, no problem there!

Oh, and one more thing: For all the benefits of this utopian society…no one has yet discovered the cure for baldness?

tos53banner2


TALES TO ASTONISH #55

tta55“On the Trail of the Human Top!”
Script: Stan Lee
Art: Dick Ayers
Letters: Art Simek

IN A NUTSHELL
When the Human Top escapes from jail, Giant-Man vows to recapture his old enemy. The Top shows up in Pym’s laboratory and steals a capsule belt. He locks Pym in the closet, and captures Wasp in a jar. The ants bring Pym a shrinking tablet, and he escapes. After Pym finds the Top, Wasp also escapes from the jar and contacts the termites. Giant-Man and a giant Top battle, until the Top falls through the rooftop that has been weakened by the termites. Giant-Man tells his fans that “even a termite can topple a giant.”

WHAT’S HOT
FAN CLUB. Giant-Man’s fans are certainly devoted! They visited him in March, when the Porcupine infiltrated their ranks, and again in April, when Wasp invited them in, simply to annoy Hank. And here they are yet again, in the splash, wearing their “Giant-Man Fan Club” jackets and buttons, while watching newsreel footage of their hero’s fantastic exploits.

But two issues remain. How do Giant-Man and Wasp maintain their secret identities when the fan club is meeting in Pym’s laboratory? Also: wouldn’t you say most of these fans appear to be way past puberty? Women who are this shapely and guys with cigarette packs on their sleeve should probably be going out on dates that don’t include fan club buttons and newsreel footage.

NOT LOSING TOUCH WITH THE LITTLE FOLK. Even though Pym can now become a giant, we still have plenty of plot points where the ants remain his faithful assistants. Here, they help him escape the closet, and termites (which are like ants, with a slightly different appetite) cause the villain to fall to his undoing. Giant-Man’s proclamation that “Even a termite can topple a giant!” reminds us not to get too hung up on size.

WHAT’S NOT
HOW BIG? And there’s another reason not to get too hung up on size. Because ever since Giant-Man first appeared, he keeps changing size! At first, we’re told he’s twelve feet tall, yet in this tall tale, he seems much more than that. Notice him tiptoeing through a crowd. Though he’s hunched over, he appears 20 feet tall, if he’s an inch! What do you think?

REALLY REALLY BIG MEETS REALLY REALLY SMALL. Ever since Giant-Man showed up, it’s been the artist’s dilemma to show the teeny tiny Wasp next to the hulkingly huge Giant-Man. How can you represent both sizes in a single comic panel? The answer is: you can’t, at least not in a way that’s going to be both accurate and visually appealing.

HO HUM… There was nothing about this story that excited me. Villain escapes, hero pursues and wins. Been there, done that. The high point in the story was the narrator’s comment in the last panel suggesting that next time, Hank and Jan may be one step closer to matrimony. Now that’s a story I want to read!

tta55banner

tta55b“The Gypsy’s Secret!”
Plot: Stan Lee
Script & Pencils: Larry Lieber
Inks: George Bell
Letters: Morrie Kuramoto

Gorko the gypsy, who can transform lead into gold, seeks assistance from greedy Baron Radzik. When Radzik insists Gorko share his secret alchemy, they travel to Gorko’s wagon…which is really a spaceship! Turns out, Gorko’s an alien, sent to earth to capture a human specimen no one will miss. On his planet, gold is the most worthless of all metal. So…Razdik gets what he wants, but it’s of absolutely no use to him.

Pretty heavy-handed moralizing, if you ask me. Also, a slight flaw in logic. Just because Razdik is a cruel, selfish, greedy, ruthless SOB doesn’t necessarily mean nobody will miss him. What about the servant who answered the castle door? Who’s going to sign his paycheck now?


sgtf7
Posted in Doctor Strange, Fantastic Four, Giant-Man, Human Torch, Iron Man, Meanwhile, Sgt. Fury, Spider-Man, Strange Tales, Tales of Suspense, Tales to Astonish, Thor, Wasp | 1 Comment

X-MEN #5: X-Ponentially Awesome

Published: May, 1964

Published: May, 1964

“Trapped! One X-Man!”
Script: Stan Lee
Pencils: Jack Kirby
Inks: Paul Reinman
Letters: Sam Rosen

For my entire adult life, my household has always contained cats. Most of the time it’s been two, and sometimes three, but at one point, for a very short time, I actually had four cats. And during that time I learned the amazing truth about mathematics and cats: four cats is SO MUCH MORE than three cats. It’s not just three plus one equals four. No, it’s three plus one equals mayhem!! Cat mischief multiplies exponentially, once you get past two or three cats.

I mention this only to introduce my observations about these last few X-Men stories. When I started reading comics, most of the time it was one superhero battling one villain. The exception has always been the Fantastic Four, and the fact that there are four of them is what makes them so exceptional in my mind. But then, a short time later, several individual heroes banded together to form the Avengers, and now THIS has become one of my favorite titles.

kittens

ALL TOGETHER NOW!
When I started reading X-Men, I thought they were okay, but not great, like the Avengers and the Fantastic Four. But now, I’m ready to step that up a notch. I think these stories now appeal to me so much more because this group of superheroes is now facing a group of super-villains. Six superheroes plus five super-villains does not equal eleven—it equals unqualified fun!

There’s so much going on in these stories, with absolutely no chance to get bored. The wild array of personalities guarantees new drama and delight at the turn of every page. Yeah, yeah, the battles are much more intense now, but that’s only half of it. If we keep going in this direction, the soap opera possibilities are going to fly right off the chart!

I sense this is only the beginning of my growing esteem for the X-Men title. But let’s start at the beginning, with a few observations I’ve made while reading this particular story.

GOOD GUYS
The X-Men suit up to help the “Hopper” track star, who is facing the wrath of an angry human crowd. It’s commendable that the X-Men want to help a fellow mutant, but if they’d taken a moment ux5hopperto think it through, they would realize the Hopper could easily hop over and escape the crowd, on his own. This guy doesn’t need their help.

Surely they’re all smart enough to realize that, but something else may be going on here, on a subconscious level. Though devastated by their beloved leader’s incapacitation, in their heart of hearts, these young X-Men know this will be an easy mission without the Professor’s help. And so they allow themselves to get all riled up, shouting, “We’ve got to help him!” and “Let’s MOVE!” Professor X approves their plan, and they rush off in a flurry of mutant pride and solidarity.

Our adolescent superheroes end up getting a lot more than they bargained for, yet they still pull it off. But I wonder if they would have been so enthusiastic if they’d known from the start they were heading out to battle not merely a crowd of disgruntled humans, but Magneto and his Brotherhood of Evil Mutants!

No matter what the X-Men must have thought, it’s clear Professor X never doubted his young charges. At no point was he without his great brain power, so he knew from the start what they were heading into. Still, he let them go. I wonder if that was a scary moment for him. It could have turned out a lot worse. But thankfully, when Dad lets go of the handlebars, Junior’s biking…without training wheels!

Wait, I take that back. There were training wheels. Professor X observed everything, mentally, from a distance, and could have stepped in at any moment to assist. But no assistance was needed. His X-Men are growing up, right before his inner eye!

PARENTS
ux5greysSo, while Professor X can be proud of his kids, it seems there’s one kid who maybe shouldn’t be so proud of her parents. As soon as the group returns from Santo Marco (X-Men #4), the doorbell rings, and it’s Jean’s parents, popping in for a visit. Quick! Everyone! Out of those “costumes”! Pick up a book and act like you’re an ordinary student! Oh hi, Mom, hi, Dad. Yeah, our teacher’s out of town, I’m just hanging around here with all my MALE classmates in this big old house…no adult supervision…

And what do Jean’s parents say? “What fine, clean-cut youngsters!” No concern at all that their sixteen-year-old daughter is the only girl among this group of teenage boys. They’re “fine” and “clean-cut,” so they must be okay. After all, “Washington D.C.” recommended the school, so it’s all got to be on the up-and-up, right?

Jean’s parents strike me as a bit…shall we say…gullible? Not only because of everything mentioned above, but when Jean’s mother admires Scott’s special sunglasses, he pulls away suddenly, claiming he has “a slight eye infection.” Admirably quick thinking for the understatement of the year! And Hank thinks quickly too, explaining away the empty Danger Room as “This is our gym! We’re getting new equipment next week!” I’ll bet if Mr. and Mrs. Grey happened to glance at Angel’s wings and he told them he was trying out for a part in the Broadway production of The Birdman of Alcatraz, they would have bought it.

BAD GUYS
Any discussion of the bad guys has to begin with Magneto. Oh, Magneto! So powerful, and yet…so frustrated. Here’s a mutant that can wrap up his enemy in steel girders, and turn bullets around in mid-flight. What can possibly harm him? He deserves the respect he so readily heaps upon himself. (His covert satellite base is “Asteroid M.” Hmmm…would that “M,” perchance, stand for…MAGNETO??)

ux5magnetoBut for someone who has such awesome power and overwhelming ego, it’s sad that the best “team” he can assemble is so rag-tag. With their constant bickering, these mutants are more comical than evil. Surely the mighty Magneto can do better than this! Or, are there such slim pickin’s among the evil mutant community?

In the previous story, Quicksilver and sister Scarlet Witch had no problem expressing disgruntlement with Magneto’s mission statement of death and destruction to all non-mutants—kill them before they kill us. Here, Scarlet Witch exclaims in horror, “Magneto! You never told me that we would ever descend to MURDER!” Well, maybe Wanda was out polishing her nails last time, when Magneto rigged a NUCLEAR BOMB. In my book, that counts as murder. Yet, Scarlet Witch just now seems to be catching on.
ux5qsw
Still, in this issue, when Magneto tries to kill the X-Men, Wanda’s conscience gets the best of her, and she hexes Magneto’s weapon before he can fire. Scott can clearly see that Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver are as out of place in the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants as a pearl onion on a banana split, so he extends an invitation to come over to the sunny side of the street.

But the offer is refused. Clinging to their old-world values, Pietro and Wanda vow to honor their obligation to remain loyal to Magneto, in exchange for a previous act of kindness he showed them. Of course, Magneto would never do anything out of kindness. When he rescued Scarlet Witch from an angry mob, he was only thinking of how this act might benefit him. But I suspect it will only be a matter of time before the siblings work out some way to convince themselves their debt has been paid, and they switch sides.

ux5mastermindNow, let’s spend a moment talking about Mastermind. Sigh… Mastermind. What a misnomer! Sure, he can conjure powerful illusions, but other than this, he’s pretty much worthless. For one thing, he gets drawn into petty arguments that take up way too many panels. For another, it’s more than hinted that Mastermind considers himself Magneto’s equal—and of course, Magneto’s having none of that.

But most disturbing of all…

Mastermind “walks past the mysterious complex of school buildings” that compose Professor Charles Xavier’s School for Gifted Youth and declares “It’s no use! The X-Men are too well hidden! No matter where I search, there is no trace of them.” So, it seems Mastermind is just swell at dishing out illusions, but hasn’t got the first clue how to uncover the simplest subterfuge of others.

ux5toadNow, a moment with Toad. Oh, Toad…so disturbingly like an abused spouse, it’s uncomfortable to watch him. He’s obviously in love with Magneto, and Magneto treats him like crap. But I can almost understand why. Those aforementioned squabbles–Toad is always right in the middle of them. Toad is always ready to tattle on his evil mutant brothers. He has no redeeming qualities, and even his superpower (he can jump really high and really far) is not all that impressive. If even a fraction of Toad’s devotion to Magneto was replaced with an equal amount of brains, he might become a force to be reckoned with. Right now, he’s just comic relief.

I hope as time goes on, Magneto will find more spectacular villains to flesh out his team. Sure it’s fun that there are so many of them, but take note of my description: Fun. More fun than danger. I wouldn’t mind seeing the X-Men having to face a bit more actual danger, when battling a group of super-villains with the ominous moniker of The Brotherhood of Evil Mutants!!

WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE?
The X-Men title is still young, still finding its way. Can this only be the fifth issue? As I’ve mentioned before, my introduction to Marvel Comics was through the X-Men movie in 2000, and I’ve seen all the X-Men movies since then, so I know we have a long way to go before getting anywhere close to what a longtime Marvel fan thinks of as the X-Men. But I have as much confidence in the Marvel bullpen to bring this title up to snuff as Professor X has in his young students, way back here, in issue 5. Obviously, there are still a number of kinks to work out, but I expect I’ll be exponentially charmed and thrilled by future issues!

ux5xmen

Want to read this comic on your computer? Marvel has a scan!
Want to own this story? Buy the Masterworks!
Posted in X-Men | 7 Comments

AVENGERS #5: Some Assembly Required

Published: May, 1964

Published: May, 1964

“The Invasion of the Lava Men!”
Script: Stan Lee
Pencils: Jack Kirby
Inks: Paul Reinman
Letters: Sam Rosen

The Marvel Universe is becoming less episodic. Over the last few months, we’ve seen more and more stories spread themselves out over two issues. We’ve also seen more references to events from previous issues cropping up to color the current action. Most exciting of all, though, is this new concept of a superhero GROUP, composed of individual superheroes we already know and love.

I just finished reading a two-part story where the Fantastic Four, with help from the Avengers, battle the always ornery Hulk. Today’s story picks up exactly where that one left off, with the Avengers inspecting the damages wrought in the previous adventure. There’s no particular plot reason to have these first couple of pages, except to establish a line of continuity, tying one story to the next. It feels awkward to tackle this Avengers story before I actually review the second installment of the Fantastic Four adventure (which will appear in the upcoming May, 1964 Meanwhile post), but Russ assures me these anomalies in continuity happen all the time in the Marvel Universe. Now that the stories are becoming less episodic, I see I’m beginning to run into that.

However, more importantly, the temporary dispersing of the group reminds us that each Avenger has another life.

DISBANDED
a5thorjaneThor suggests they disband since they all have “personal matters to attend to.” We can only imagine that for Thor, those “personal matters” are likely to include further strategizing on how to get father Odin to approve his marriage to the love of his life, Jane Foster.

Iron Man also has issues that need his attention. Tony Stark, the “millionaire playboy industrialist,” not only has to call in a contractor to repair his damaged mansion (mere pocket change…), but he constantly needs to take precautions against “the threat of sudden death due to the piece of shrapnel” that could kill him at any moment.

It’s a heavy load to bear. Almost as heavy as his personal qualifier, “millionaire playboy industrialist.” And, as we know, he’s also a philanthropist (remember those a5imvisits to entertain orphans?). But thank goodness, we aren’t reminded of THAT on a constant basis, as well!

Oh! And did I happen to mention…one handsome devil? That’s another cross Tony must bear, so often included in his lengthy list of descriptors. However, in this story, Stark merely mentions his “alleged good looks.” He’s alone when he says this, so we assume he’s talking to himself, not trying to impress anyone with his humility (“the HUMBLE handsome millionaire playboy industrialist philanthropist”). But it makes you wonder: does Tony really not know how handsome he is??? Or, perhaps, being keenly aware of his many positive attributes, does the illustrious Tony Stark constantly endeavor to studiously practice humility, so that even when he’s alone, he tries desperately to convince himself he’s not as wonderful as he really knows he is?

All of this is a lot to deal with, when you’re not busy being an Avenger.

a5caCaptain America fares a little better during his off time. He’s attached himself to his pseudo-Bucky-buddy, Rick Jones, and through him, the entire Teen Brigade. Here Cap is in his element, entertaining and coaching American youth with heavy-handed messages about “why it’s so vitally important to eat the right foods and get plenty of exercise and eight hours of sleep!”

The Teen Brigade doesn’t seem to mind the lectures, though. They’re on Cloud Nine–they’ve got a real live superhero in their midst! They’re so jazzed by all this, when Cap says, “You guys wait here while Rick and I go off to meet with the Avengers,” they can’t even find it in their hearts to be jealous of the favored Brigade member. They just gush, “Gosh! How lucky can he be?” no doubt wondering if the day will ever come when Cap picks THEM for the side kick gig. (And he just might–if only they eat the right foods, and get plenty of exercise and sleep!)

a5antmanwaspMeanwhile, Ant-Man and Wasp have slipped back into their routine, which involves playful bickering and obsessing over isotope action in an ant hill. It’s a tough job, but somebody’s got to do it.

TEAMWORK!
Of course, all this takes a back seat to more Avengers action, when the subterranean Lava Men push an explosive Living Rock to earth’s surface, so it can wipe out humanity and leave “whatever remains of our once-proud civilization” for the Lava Men to re-cultivate.

Such a cataclysmic possibility calls back into service not only the Avengers, but also scientist Bruce Banner, who’s using the cover story that he’s been ill, but he’s better now. Betty Ross makes a guest appearance, encouraging Bruce to solve the Living Rock mystery, as it a5brucemay help her tyrannical parent, General “Thunderbolt” Ross, “feel differently about you… about us!” (Incidentally, in this issue, I finally figure out how General Ross got the nickname “Thunderbolt”: is there EVER a time when this guy is not YELLING at someone??)

Before Banner can be of much scientific use, however, he morphs into Hulk and approaches the Avengers—-like they haven’t got enough on their plate, with an exploding Living Rock and army of Lava Men to fight!

But these Avengers are level-headed crusaders who take things one step at a time. Upon arriving on the scene and finding the Living Rock, Iron Man quickly announces that he’ll investigate. When Rick Jones questions, “Wait! What about the rest of us??” Cap replies, “You HEARD the man, Rick! We don’t question each other’s commands! Iron Man must have his reasons!”

At which point, I’m asking myself: And how exactly does that work? We have a crew of Alpha super-beings who are all accustomed to being large and in charge when accomplishing their own superhero exploits. Each believes that HE has what it takes to finish the job. You don’t survive as a superhero by trusting that someone else will step in to take care of business. No, it’s you or no one, it’s now or never. That’s how superheroes work.

In that upcoming Fantastic Four story I referenced earlier, there’s a wonderful example of how too much superhero mojo can gum up the works. We’ll talk about that in the Meanwhile post, but for a sneak peek, click here.

So, how does this group learn to function as a TEAM?

I’m thinking about football. A football team practices together over a long period of time to learn each other’s movements and nuances, as well as develop game plans and strategies. Muscle memory is enforced, as impeccable timing develops. But we don’t see the Avengers getting together for “superhero practice” (like the X-Men do, exhaustively). With their many divided interests (science, medicine, industry, philanthropy and romance, as well as their individual superhero careers), unless they all count “Intuitively Knowing When to Strike, And When to Hold Back” among their superhero powers, I’ve got to wonder how they get this show up and running smoothly.

But I’m not wondering for long. Almost immediately I realize: this group, the Avengers, is composed of some pretty smart dudes. Stark didn’t get to be a millionaire playboy industrialist philanthropist without also being intelligent. Pym’s a scientist, and Thor is a GOD. Maybe they all DO intuitively know when to strike, and when to hold back.

a5lavamanAs they approach the Living Rock, Iron Man decides to go in first, because his armor will protect him from radiation. But when he finds the heat of the Lava Men unbearable, he pulls back, and the heartier Thor takes up the mantle.

Meanwhile, Hank and Jan shrink to make a detailed examination of the Living Rock, and scientist Pym discovers some invaluable information. He sees “one small area which isn’t pulsating” and instantly deduces that “if a strong enough blow could strike this exact spot, it would destroy the rock without causing a cataclysmic explosion!”

Oh, really? How does he know this? How can he be certain that striking the rock on that one small area is not the very thing that causes an explosion so intense it blows up the solar system? Nobody has ever seen anything like this Living Rock before, and yet Pym is willing to hang the survival of the human race upon this leap of faith.

That’s not the point, though. The point is that when Giant-Man becomes Ant-Man and employs the Pym brain to come up with the solution to the problem (no matter how far-fetched that solution may seem), he’s using his smarts to make his own unique contribution.

We’ll look past Pym’s far-fetched hunch, and also look past the “freak one-in-a-million combination of molecules” that magically causes Thor to revert to Don Blake, at the precise moment it’s assumed that only a blow from Thor’s hammer can save the planet.

a5hulkIt’s all so terribly inconvenient. And dramatic. But that’s not the point, and anyway, it doesn’t matter. Because what happens next?

The Avengers put their super brains together to form Plan B. “The Wasp and I have a plan,” Giant-Man announces, and Wasp adds, “It was Captain America’s idea!” Now we’re working together, like a well-oiled machine! Giant-Man lures Hulk to the magic spot on the Living Rock, then confuses him with his amazing size-shifting. Cap further “dazzles” Hulk with his spinning shield, while Wasp annoys the not-so-jolly green giant and gets him to strike the Living Rock in exactly the right place at exactly the right split-second.

a5thorWith Thor missing in action, the remaining Avengers have tricked the disgruntled former Avenger into saving the world of puny humans. Hulk isn’t even a functioning member of the group, but the others know how to push his buttons and make him do what they need him to do.

So. Turns out there are actually TWO forces that can strike a strong enough blow to cause the Living Rock to implode rather than explode: one is Thor’s hammer, but the other is Hulk’s fist.

And, conveniently, though the first is unavailable, the second works like a charm. And the world is saved. Again.

Mile-wide coincidences and gaping plot holes aside, by the end of this story, I’m asking myself a different question: if the Avengers are this good without team practice, how awesome would they be if they forsook “disbanding” after an adventure, and hung out together to have pizza (or shawarma…) and get in some super-charged superhero practice?

QLEAPBut there won’t be time for practice any time soon! This story ends with the Teen Brigade sending a “Condition Red” emergency notice, and so another adventure starts before the Avengers even have a chance to take a breath. Kind of reminds me of Quantum Leap, where at the end of every episode, Sam would time-travel to his next assignment. Sam’s customary “Oh, boy!” is here translated into Iron Man’s final panel exclamation of “Let’s go!!”

But that, my friends, is another story…

a5finale

Want to read this comic on your computer? Marvel has a scan!
Want to own this story? Buy the Masterworks!
Posted in Avengers | Leave a comment